Hello guest! Are you an Apistogramma enthusiast? If so we invite you to join our community and see what it has to offer. Our site is specifically designed for you and it's a great place for Apisto enthusiasts to meet online. Once you join you'll be able to post messages, upload pictures of your fish and tanks and have a great time with other Apisto enthusiasts. Sign up today!
I am not familiar with this species. No 1 is a great looking fish. No 2 looks completly different Are they from distinctly different areas. When were these discovered?
You probably know it as "A. wilhelmi", a terrible name. That name makes it appear to be a scientifically described species, which it is not! "A. sp. Abacaxis", at least, indicates that it is an undescribed species and that it is found in the Rio Abacaxis (A227). Horst Linke and Mario Wilhelm collected A227 in 1999 and Linke introduced it into the hobby as 'A. sp. "Wilhelmi" (sadly abbreviated by others soon afterward). "A. cf. sp. Abacaxis (Marimari)" (A228) is found in the nearby Rio Marimari, both in Brazil. It (A228) was imported into Japan in 2002 as "A. pulchra from Marimari" There is little difference between the 2 forms, other than the pattern in the caudal fin. They are probably only populations of the same species.
Ricardo, I am not surprised about the mix of populations. Collecting stations/exporters probably mixed fish from more than one collector. The forms easily interbreed (for this species). I had to do this when I only had males of A228 and females of A227. The resulting males had both and intermediate caudal patterns.
Nicolas, I cannot be certain about your male. The body (and lateral band) is too pale. On A227 the lateral band extends only slightly beyond the root of the caudal; on A228 the lateral band extends farther into the caudal.
Crossing forms/populations is something I personally try to avoid if at all possible. Sometimes, with rarely available fish, it is necessary. I see nothing really wrong with mixing populations/forms if they are the same species. I just don't like to do it if at all possible.